Skip to main content

settlement money from meso lawsuit - do you actually have to pay taxes on it

Family · · 35 views
So I'm starting to deal with my dad's case and our lawyer mentioned something about tax implications that honestly went over my head a little bit. He's Stage IV pleural meso, diagnosed back in March, and we're looking at what might come from a settlement down the line. The lawyer said something about how certain parts of the settlement aren't taxable but other parts are and I need to understand this better before we move forward.

As a nurse practitioner I deal with medical stuff all day but tax law is completely outside my wheelhouse, and I don't want to get blindsided by a huge tax bill if we do settle. Like, if he gets $500K or whatever, are we losing a chunk of that to federal taxes or is there some protection built in for meso settlements specifically.

Anyone been through this already? Did your settlement have tax consequences and how did your lawyer handle explaining it? I'm in Chicago if that matters for state tax stuff. I just need to know what questions to ask before we get deeper into this process because right now I'm managing his palliative care and honestly the legal side is making my brain hurt on top of everything else.

8 Replies

Family
Oh man, I feel this so hard. My mom got her diagnosis in August and suddenly I'm trying to learn about legal stuff I never thought I'd need to know while also trying to be present for her, you know? It's a lot.

So from what our lawyer explained to us here in Phoenix, the physical injury settlement part is usually not taxable, which is the bulk of what you'd get. But then there's stuff like punitive damages or interest that can be taxable, and that's where it gets messy. Our guy broke it down pretty clearly in like September when we first started talking settlement possibilities, and honestly that conversation made a huge difference in understanding what we're actually looking at.

The thing is every case is different and your state might handle it differently than Arizona does, so I wouldn't want to steer you wrong on the specifics. But I will say this: ask your lawyer to write down exactly which parts of any settlement offer are taxable and which aren't, and don't let them move forward until you have that in writing. I also asked about talking to a tax professional separately, like a CPA who deals with this stuff, because they can look at it from a different angle than the meso lawyer can.

Your brain hurting is totally valid btw. I'm literally juggling my fifth graders all day and then coming home to care stuff and legal stuff and some days I feel like I'm failing at all of it. But you're doing better than you think you are, even when it doesn't feel like it.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
So the general rule under IRC Section 104 is that compensation for physical injuries is excluded from federal gross income, and that actually does cover most of what comes out of a meso settlement. The part that trips people up is anything designated as punitive damages or lost wages, because those portions can be taxable. Your lawyer should be itemizing how the settlement is structured, and honestly asking them specifically how each category is labeled in the settlement agreement is worth doing before you sign anything.

Illinois also has its own income tax picture so a CPA who works with personal injury settlements specifically is worth talking to, not just your regular tax person. I've seen families in similar situations work with a tax professional before finalizing the agreement because how the settlement is written can actually affect what's owed.

And given that you're already carrying the weight of his palliative care coordination... please don't try to absorb all of this alone. Journaling what questions come up as you go through documents has helped some people I've worked with just keep track of what they need to ask without everything blurring together.
3 found this helpful
Family
Yeah, that IRC Section 104 thing is what our lawyer mentioned but he kinda breezed past it. So if I'm understanding right, the physical injury compensation piece should be protected but I need to make sure he's actually breaking down the settlement into those categories before we sign anything. Did you find that most lawyers proactively do this or did you have to push back and ask them to spell it out? I'm worried because right now my dad's just exhausted and I don't want him stressed about legal details on top of managing pain, so I'm trying to get ahead of this stuff myself.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
The Chicago piece you mentioned is worth a quick note... Illinois actually conforms to the federal exclusion pretty closely, so that's one less layer to stress about. But the piece that catches families off guard isn't the settlement itself, it's what happens when the money gets invested afterward. Any interest or dividends the settlement generates after it's received, that's ordinary income. We had a family in our support group last spring who got a significant settlement and then felt totally blindsided come tax time the following April because nobody had flagged that part early enough. A fee-only CPA who specifically works with personal injury settlements is worth the couple hundred dollars for a consult before anything gets finalized, just to map out where the taxable edges actually are.
2 found this helpful
Family
Yeah that's the part that's been nagging at me too. So the settlement itself is protected but then if my dad's money sits in an account and starts earning interest, that becomes taxable income. That makes sense logically but it's such a trap because people assume the whole thing is protected and then get surprised come tax time. Did that family in your support group end up working with a financial advisor to manage it, or did they figure it out after the fact? I'm trying to get ahead of this so we're not scrambling.
Family
Oh man, I totally get that brain fog. I'm juggling my mom's care stuff and a full time job and honestly some days I can barely remember what day it is, let alone follow legal jargon. So you're definitely not alone in feeling overwhelmed by the tax stuff.

Our lawyer walked us through it pretty carefully once I asked him to slow down and explain it like I wasn't a lawyer. The way he broke it down was that physical injury settlements usually aren't taxable, but things like punitive damages or pain and suffering can get tricky depending on how they're classified in the settlement agreement. He was really clear that we needed to get a CPA involved who specializes in this stuff, not just our regular tax person. We ended up meeting with someone he recommended back in September and it cost like $400 for a consultation but honestly it was worth it just to not feel completely in the dark.

What helped me was writing down specific questions before meetings instead of trying to absorb everything on the fly. Like "what parts of a potential settlement would be taxable" and "what documentation do we need to keep." Your lawyer should be able to walk you through it but if they're not explaining it in a way that makes sense, that's actually a red flag that maybe you need someone else in the room.

The palliative care stuff plus legal stuff plus your actual job is a lot. Like I literally had to take a personal day last month because I just broke down in the teacher's lounge and I teach fourth graders who ask why Mrs. Helen is sad. You're doing way more than most people could handle right now.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
What you're going through right now, managing his palliative care AND trying to wrap your head around legal and financial stuff at the same time, that's an enormous amount to carry. Be gentle with yourself here.

From what I've seen sitting with families in similar situations, the general rule under IRC Section 104 is that compensation for physical injury and illness is excluded from federal income tax. So the bulk of a meso settlement tied directly to his diagnosis and suffering tends to be protected. But the parts that can get taxable are things like punitive damages or any portion tied to lost wages that were previously deducted somewhere. Your lawyer flagged it for a reason, so definitely push them to break down exactly which bucket each piece of the settlement falls into.

Illinois does follow the federal exclusion on personal injury settlements, which is worth knowing since you mentioned Chicago. I'd still get a CPA or tax attorney in the loop before anything is finalized, someone who specifically handles personal injury proceeds because the general tax preparer at an H&R Block on Michigan Avenue probably hasn't seen a meso case before.

One thing families I've worked with have found really grounding during this phase is keeping a running document of every question that surfaces, even the ones that feel half-formed. Kind of like journaling but practical. It helps so much when you're sitting across from your attorney and your brain is already exhausted from everything else.

If the stress is becoming persistent and hard to manage, please know that oncology social work support exists specifically for this season of life. You don't have to white-knuckle through it.
2 found this helpful
Family
Joe's lawyer should definitely break down the taxable vs non-taxable portions for you because it does matter, but honestly a tax accountant who knows meso cases is gonna be your best friend here. We had our CPA sit in on some of those conversations and it made way more sense coming from someone who speaks that language, you know?

Share Your Experience

Sign in or create a free account to share your experience.

Discussions in this community are for informational and emotional support purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice, medical advice, or an attorney-client relationship. Always consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Community Guidelines

Call Now: (800) 400-1805 Free Case Review • Available 24/7