Skip to main content

what actually is tumor treating fields and should my dad consider it

Family · · 29 views
So my dad got diagnosed Stage IV pleural in March and we've been doing palliative care since October. His oncologist at Northwestern mentioned TTFields as something to think about and I honestly have no idea what it actually does or if it's worth pursuing at this point.

I know enough medicine to be dangerous but tumor treating fields is kind of outside my wheelhouse. From what I'm reading it's like electric therapy that disrupts cancer cell division but I'm seeing conflicting stuff online about whether it actually extends survival or just makes people feel like they're doing something. And at Stage IV pleural with how he's feeling right now I'm not even sure it's realistic.

Has anyone's parent or spouse done TTFields? Like what was the actual experience and did you see any benefit or was it just more appointments and more stuff attached to them. My dad is already pretty fatigued and the idea of wearing electrode arrays under his skin sounds rough but if it actually gave him more time I want to know that.

Also curious if anyone knows whether palliative care folks typically recommend this or if it's more of an aggressive treatment center thing. We're not really in active treatment mode anymore so I'm wondering if that changes the equation.

11 Replies

Patient
Hang in there buddy. Stage IV is a whole different ballgame than where I'm sitting with Stage I, so I gotta be honest that my experience might not map onto your dad's situation at all.

But here's what I know from talking to folks at the support group and my oncology team at Henry Ford. TTFields is basically like running a tuneup on cancer cells, messes with their ability to divide. The thing is, at Stage IV palliative care, your docs are really weighing quality of life against the odds of extension. My surgeon said it works better earlier on when the tumor burden isn't as heavy, which... that ain't your dad's spot right now.

The electrode thing is real though. My buddy Tom's wife did it for ovarian and she said wearing the vest under her shirt all day, managing the adhesive patches, charging the device, keeping appointments for the monitoring. By month three she was just exhausted from the logistics of it, not even counting the cancer exhaustion she already had. For someone already running on fumes like your dad sounds, that's alot to ask.

Palliative care docs I've talked to tend to be honest about this stuff. If they're mentioning it, they might see something worth trying, but they should also be real about whether it fits with your dad's actual goals right now. That's the question I'd ask Northwestern directly, not the internet. What's the realistic timeline they're seeing and what does your dad actually want these last months to look like.
Family
I appreciate you being real about the stage difference, that actually helps. Yeah the QoL piece is what's been keeping me up at night honestly. My dad's already dealing with pretty significant fatigue and fluid buildup, and I guess I'm trying to figure out if adding another device and more appointments would just add burden without meaningful payoff at this point. Did your support group folks who were Stage IV and on palliative care, did any of them actually try it or did most people skip it once they transitioned away from active treatment?
Veteran
Never did TTFields myself but watched a shipmate's wife go through it back at Naval Station Norfolk around 1400 hours one afternoon, sat in the waiting room with him. She had Stage III and wore the vest under her clothes, said it was itchy as hell and the appointments were constant. What I remember most was my buddy saying the oncologist kept saying it "extends progression-free survival" but his wife's energy tanked even more from wearing the thing, and they stopped after four months because quality of life just wasn't there anymore. Stage IV is different beast entirely. Your old man's already running on fumes with palliative care. That's the real question right there, not whether TTFields works in a lab somewhere. It works great on paper. Real life is messier. At what point does another treatment become another thing stealing what time he's got left? That's between him and his docs at Northwestern but I'd want to know exactly what "benefit" means in his specific case before strapping anything to his chest.
Medical Expert Response
The STELLAR trial is probably the study you want to look at. It showed median overall survival of 18.2 months for TTFields plus chemotherapy in pleural mesothelioma, compared to about 12 months for chemo alone. That was published in Lancet Oncology in 2023 and it's what got TTFields FDA cleared for this indication. So the data isn't just people feeling like they're doing something, there's real signal there.

But the experience question is where it gets complicated. The device involves electrode arrays worn on the chest, and patients use it at least 18 hours a day for it to have meaningful effect. For someone already fatigued, that's a real conversation to have honestly. I've seen patients tolerate it well and feel like the routine gave them some sense of control. I've also seen patients where the burden just wasn't worth it given where they were in their illness.

The palliative vs. aggressive treatment framing is worth revisiting with his team. Palliative care is about quality of life and symptom management, which doesn't automatically mean no disease-directed treatment. Some patients in palliative mode do pursue TTFields specifically because it's not chemotherapy and the side effect profile is mostly skin irritation rather than systemic toxicity. That distinction matters at this stage.

What I'd want to know in your position is what his performance status looks like right now and whether his Northwestern team thinks he's a realistic candidate given his current fatigue level. That's genuinely the question that changes the equation more than anything else. Talk to his oncologist about the specifics of his case before making any decisions based on the trial data.
4 found this helpful
Family
Yeah I actually found that STELLAR trial yesterday and that's what got me thinking about this more seriously. The 18.2 months versus 12 is significant enough that I can't just dismiss it, even though I know correlation isn't everything. My concern though is that trial data and real world palliative care are pretty different things, especially for someone already dealing with significant fatigue. Did those patients in the trial have similar baseline performance status to someone already on palliative care, or were they more actively treatment-focused? I guess I'm trying to figure out if my dad even fits the profile for it to help or if we're looking at quality of life trade-offs that don't make sense at this point.
Family
Yeah, so TTFields is basically low-intensity electrical current that disrupts microtubule formation during mitosis. The mechanism is solid and the data from the STELLAR trial showed it did extend progression-free survival in mesothelioma when combined with chemo, but that's a pretty specific population and honestly the benefit was measured in weeks, not months. Maybe 2-3 months median PFS improvement if I'm remembering right.

Here's what nobody tells you though. We looked into it for my dad back in April when he was still in active treatment mode and his oncologist at Northwestern (we're at the same system actually) was pretty honest about the reality. At Stage IV with palliative focus, the calculus changes completely. TTFields requires wearing these electrode arrays under a vest basically 18+ hours a day. You have to shave the areas, deal with skin irritation, there's the weight of the device, and you're tethered to a power supply. For someone already exhausted from advanced disease progression, that's a lot of physical burden for a statistical maybe.

What convinced us not to pursue it was that my dad's fatigue was already limiting his quality time and the electrode therapy would've added another layer of physical constraint on top of everything else. We made peace with that decision pretty quickly because his palliative care team (which includes his oncologist) was really clear that the goal shifted to comfort and meaningful time, not extending survival metrics by a few weeks.

The skin irritation people report is real though. Some folks get dermatitis pretty bad and you can't just take a break from it because the treatment loses efficacy. And honestly at this stage with your dad already struggling with energy, I'd ask his team whether the downside risk to his remaining quality time is worth a maybe 2-3 week extension. That's the conversation worth having rather than diving into the clinical data.

How's he feeling day to day right now?
Family
my mom tried it for a couple months and honestly it just felt like one more thing wearing her out, especially since she was already pretty tired like your dad. we ended up stopping because her quality of life mattered more than chasing something that wasn't really showing results for her.
Patient
honestly at Stage IV I'd ask the oncologist straight up if it's gonna actually buy him more time or if they're just throwing everything at it, cause that's the real question right there. my gut says palliative folks usually aren't pushing the heavy stuff but could be wrong.
Family
Yeah that's exactly what I've been wrestling with. I did ask point blank and the oncologist was honest that the data shows maybe a few months median extension, not years, and that's in patients who tolerate it well. My dad's been pretty clear he doesn't want to trade quality time now for a slim chance at more time later, especially if it means feeling worse in the meantime. I think that answers it for us but I appreciate you saying the quiet part out loud because it does feel like sometimes the default is to do something rather than sit with palliative care.
Family
Joe did the TTFields thing for about four months starting back in January. His oncologist at Moffitt Cancer Center brought it up kind of the same way yours did, like it was an option worth exploring even though we weren't doing chemo anymore.

Honestly the experience was... mixed. The device itself isn't as invasive as it sounds, it's these electrode patches you stick on your skin under your shirt, kind of like a portable unit about the size of a lunch box that you carry around. Joe wore it like 18 to 20 hours a day and the biggest complaint wasn't pain or anything, it was just the logistics of it all. You have to keep the patches clean, replace them every few days, manage the wires, deal with occasional skin irritation. For someone already tired it becomes one more thing.

The thing about TTFields is the clinical data shows it can extend survival by a few months in certain mesothelioma cases, but we're talking modest numbers and your dad's already at Stage IV which is different than where most of the research was done. Joe's oncologist was honest that it wasn't going to be a game changer for him specifically but said some patients did tolerate it okay and if he wanted to try it we could always stop.

We ended up stopping after four months because honestly he just wasn't feeling any different and the fatigue you mentioned was real. He didn't have energy to do the things he actually wanted to do, and adding this device management on top of that felt like we were choosing the treatment over actually living. His palliative care team supported that decision completely, no pushback. They said their job was quality of life not just extending it by a few weeks.

I taught high school for 30 years and learned that sometimes the best lesson plans are the ones you're willing to abandon halfway through if they're not working. That's kind of how we approached it. Your dad knowing what he's willing to tolerate matters more than what the data says...

How's your dad feeling about it? Like does he want to try something or is he pretty settled where he's at?
Family
That's really helpful to hear about the actual setup, because yeah everything I read made it sound like major surgery or something. So Joe just wore patches and carried the box around, that's way less intense than what I was picturing. Did he have to keep it on 24/7 or could he take breaks, and more importantly did you guys notice any actual changes in how he was feeling or his scans during those four months?

Share Your Experience

Sign in or create a free account to share your experience.

Discussions in this community are for informational and emotional support purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice, medical advice, or an attorney-client relationship. Always consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Community Guidelines

Call Now: (800) 400-1805 Free Case Review • Available 24/7