Skip to main content

picking a treatment center for Joe's stage III pleural meso - what actually mattered to us

Family · · 48 views
So we're about three months into this now and I keep thinking about how we picked where Joe would do his immunotherapy and honestly I wish I'd known what to ask back in September when we first got the diagnosis.

We started by just calling the big cancer centers Tampa area and that was a mistake because everyone sounded the same on the phone. What actually helped was talking to people on here who'd already gone through it, and then Dr. Morrison at Moffitt actually sat down with us for like forty minutes and walked through not just the protocol but what the side effects would look like for Joe specifically because he's got a heart thing from years back. That mattered.

I was a teacher for thirty four years so I know how to ask questions and read between the lines, but even I got overwhelmed by the medical jargon. What I looked for was whether they had a dedicated meso team that actually talked to each other, not just a oncologist who sees meso cases sometimes. And whether they had someone who could explain the plan in regular English. Joe's immunotherapy started in November and we're seeing some real response which is why I'm writing this now.

The distance thing is real too. We're in Tampa and we could've gone to Houston or up to New York but the weekly appointments and the fact that Joe gets tired after treatment meant staying local was huge for us. Some people can travel but honestly after an infusion he just wants to be home.

And ask about clinical trials. Not every center has the same access to trials and depending on your staging that might be the difference in your options. Moffitt had three different trials Joe qualified for.

What helped you guys decide where to go?

10 Replies

Veteran
Good thread, M. We faced something similar back in August when I had my pleurectomy at Naval Medical Center Portsmouth. The big thing nobody tells you is that the surgeon's experience with meso specifically matters way more than the hospital's name. I called around and asked each one straight up how many pleural meso cases they'd done in the last two years. One place gave me a number, another guy got defensive about it. Went with the first one.

The dedicated team thing you mentioned is exactly right. At Portsmouth they had the thoracic surgeon, pulmonologist, and oncology all in the same building and they actually communicated before my appointments instead of me being the messenger between departments. Made a huge difference in the recovery plan post-op.

Distance was less of an issue for me being military and all but I get it. I was doing physical therapy three times a week and couldn't imagine driving to Norfolk from somewhere else every time. Your point about being tired after treatment is spot on. After my surgery I was wiped out just sitting in a car for twenty minutes.

One thing we didn't do that I wish we had: asked about their meso support resources before we picked. Not just clinical stuff but whether they had social workers who actually understood this diagnosis. Turns out that mattered more to my wife than it did to me.

Joe's response sounds solid. Keep pushing them to explain things in plain language. That's how you know they actually understand it themselves.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
What you described about Dr. Morrison sitting for forty minutes and actually factoring in Joe's cardiac history, that's not standard everywhere and it really should be. The dedicated meso team piece is the thing I'd echo most strongly. There's real data on this. The IASLC (International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer) published work showing mesothelioma patients treated at high-volume specialty centers had meaningfully better outcomes, partly because the multidisciplinary team, pulmonology, oncology, thoracic surgery, pathology, is meeting regularly and actually talking about each individual case.

The clinical trial access question is one I wish more families asked upfront. Not every NCI-designated cancer center has the same trial portfolio and mesothelioma is rare enough that some of the most promising trials are only open at maybe eight or ten sites nationally. When I was doing a fellowship rotation at Memorial Sloan Kettering back in 2014, I saw firsthand how differently the options looked for patients who came there versus patients who'd only been seen in community settings.

And the distance piece is so real. There's no right answer there. Someone with good local support and a partner who gets tired after infusions is making a completely rational call staying close to home.

The response you're seeing in November... that's what you hold onto. Talk to your oncologist about what the imaging markers are telling them and what the benchmark response looks like at each cycle.
3 found this helpful
Family
That cardiac history piece really stuck with us too, honestly. Joe was so nervous they'd just say "no, too risky" but Dr. Morrison actually looked at his specific situation instead of just going by the handbook. And yeah, the multidisciplinary team thing... I could tell the difference just from how the appointments felt. Like everyone actually knew what the others were doing instead of us having to repeat his whole history five times.

Do you see that data gap a lot, where patients don't realize the volume and teamwork actually affects their outcomes?
Family
You're hitting on something really important here and I'm glad Joe's responding well. The dedicated team thing is exactly what we found too. When we first called around in September it felt like we were just another appointment slot, you know? But Dr. Morrison actually knowing Joe's medical history going in made all the difference.

I think because I spent so long in the classroom I was used to advocating but man, medical stuff is different. You can't just grade it on a curve. What got me was asking them straight up "how many meso cases do you see a month" and then "who's the person I call if Joe has a problem on a Sunday." The centers that hesitated on that second question, we didn't go there. Moffitt had a whole protocol for it which honestly felt good.

The fatigue after treatment is real and underestimated. We live about twenty minutes from Moffitt and even that sometimes feels like too much on infusion days. I can't imagine doing weekly Houston runs like some folks here do. Props to them but Joe just needs his own couch and his dog and quiet.

One thing nobody really told us upfront: ask about their social worker or patient navigator. Ours helped us understand what insurance would and wouldn't cover before we got surprised by a bill. That saved us stress we didn't need.

How far are you from wherever you're looking at going?
Patient
Yeah man, picking the right spot is like finding a good mechanic for your car, you know? You gotta trust em and they gotta actually listen to what's going on under the hood.

I did my EPP surgery at University of Michigan back in February and honestly the biggest thing for me was that they had done a ton of these procedures. Like their thoracic surgeon knew meso inside and out, not just "oh yeah we do that sometimes." I called like six different places first and you could tell real quick who was gonna be straight with you and who was just running through a script.

The travel thing hit different for me too. Detroit to Ann Arbor is only like 45 minutes so I could do my follow-ups without making it this whole production. My wife didn't have to take off work every time. That stuff adds up fast, trust me on that one.

One thing nobody told me before surgery was to ask about their complication rates and what their aftercare looks like. Like not just the surgery itself but the next three months when you're healing. Moffitt sounds solid about that stuff with Joe's heart history and all. That's the kind of thing that separates the good centers from the ones just going through the motions.

Glad you're seeing response with the immunotherapy. That's huge. And yeah, the clinical trials thing is real, we looked at a couple before I went the surgery route but didn't qualify for the ones available to me.
Family
Yeah that mechanic analogy is perfect, honestly. And you're spot on about experience - that's exactly what we found matters most. Dr. Morrison had done so many of these cases that when he talked about what to expect, it didn't feel like he was reading from a script, you know? He'd already seen what works and what doesn't with meso specifically.

How'd you end up choosing Michigan over some of the closer options? And how are you doing post-surgery now?
Family
we're at Northwestern and honestly the meso-specific team made all the difference too, they actually coordinate between oncology and pulmonology instead of just throwing everything at the wall. the clinical trial piece is huge, that's what we didn't know to ask about initially and it expanded what was available to him.
Family
Oh that's so good to hear about the coordination between departments, that's exactly what I mean. It sounds like Northwestern really has their act together with how the teams talk to each other. And yeah the clinical trials thing is wild once you realize how much it changes what's actually on the table for you... Joe's oncologist mentioned there's a couple trials he might age into next year depending on how he responds to the current protocol. Do you feel like the trial they went with was the right call for him?
Patient
I'm still in the evaluation phase for HIPEC so I haven't had surgery yet, but I've been doing exactly what you did, M - calling around and asking the tough questions. What nobody mentioned to me until I dug into the actual published outcomes was whether the center tracks their own meso-specific complication rates. Not just general surgical complication rates from all their cases, but peritoneal meso specifically. I found one study from 2023 that showed centers doing 15+ HIPEC procedures annually had significantly better outcomes than those doing fewer, so I literally called four hospitals and asked them their annual volume. Two wouldn't even tell me. The one that did said 22 last year and I'm leaning that direction now. Also I've been keeping a detailed symptom journal since my diagnosis in November and I'm bringing that to every consultation because it helps the doctors see the actual progression pattern instead of just going by imaging. One surgeon looked at my notes from October through now and said it actually changed how he'd approach staging the procedure. The distance thing is tough for me too since I'm in Cleveland and the best meso teams aren't exactly nearby, but I'm trying to figure out if I can do the pre-op stuff locally and then travel for the actual surgery plus immediate recovery. Still working that piece out.
Family
That's such a smart thing to look into, Patricia. Honestly when we were going through this I didn't even know to ask about those kinds of specifics, I was just listening to whether they sounded confident. But you're right that the volume and their actual track record with meso cases is what matters, not just being a big name center. How many places in your area are doing that many HIPEC procedures a year?

Share Your Experience

Sign in or create a free account to share your experience.

Discussions in this community are for informational and emotional support purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice, medical advice, or an attorney-client relationship. Always consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Community Guidelines

Call Now: (800) 400-1805 Free Case Review • Available 24/7