Skip to main content
Content Medically Reviewed & Updated: June 14, 2026 Call 24/7: 1-800-400-1805
1-800-400-1805 Free Case Review
Sign In Join Free

settlement money and taxes - what actually gets taxed and what doesn't

Family · · 68 views
So I'm trying to figure out the tax stuff because my mom's case might actually settle and I have no idea what that means for her financially. Like, is the whole amount taxable or just part of it? I've heard conflicting things from different people and I'm honestly tired of asking questions that make me feel stupid.

She's been through so much already with the EPP back in September and the chemo rounds, and now I'm supposed to understand tax law on top of everything else? I work full-time teaching fourth graders in Phoenix and trying to manage her care appointments and honestly some days I just sit in my car at school before I go home and cry because there's too much happening at once.

Anyone been through this who can explain it in plain English? Like what portion actually gets taxed versus what's considered non-taxable because it's for medical stuff or lost wages or whatever. And do we need to hire someone special to handle this or can our regular accountant figure it out.

Thanks for any help. I'm really trying to stay on top of things but this part feels impossible.

11 Replies

Veteran
get a tax person who knows mesothelioma cases, regular accountant won't know the specifics and you'll end up paying more than you should. worth the cost upfront, trust me on this one.
Family
That's really good to know, honestly. I was hoping our regular guy could handle it but it sounds like that's not smart. Did you end up finding someone through your lawyer's office or did you have to search on your own? I'm worried about adding another person to the list of people I need to coordinate with but if it saves us money in the long run it's probably worth it.
Family
Oh man, I get this so much. After my mom's diagnosis last August I was googling "mesothelioma settlement taxes" at like 11pm in my pajamas thinking I had to become a tax expert overnight. You're not stupid at all, this stuff is genuinely confusing and nobody explains it well.

So from what we learned with my mom's case, the basic thing is that different parts of a settlement get treated differently. Medical expenses and lost wages are usually non-taxable, which is huge. But stuff like punitive damages or interest can be taxable. The problem is figuring out exactly what portion falls into which bucket, and honestly that's where you really do need someone who knows this stuff specifically.

We ended up hiring a CPA who had worked with other mesothelioma cases before. Our regular accountant basically said "yeah I have no idea" which I appreciated them being honest about. The specialist one cost more but she literally walked us through every line item and what the IRS considers taxable and what doesn't. It gave me so much peace of mind. I think we found her through asking at the law firm handling the case, and they had recommendations.

The other thing I'll say is don't feel like you need to understand all this before the settlement happens. Like yes you want to be prepared but you don't need to have it all figured out right now while you're also teaching fourth graders and driving your mom to oncology appointments. That's insane. Get a specialist when it's actually close to settling and let them do their job.

You're doing so much already. This part will work out.
Family
Hey, you're not stupid at all. This stuff is legitimately confusing and honestly most people have no idea how it works until they're in it. I'm in the same boat right now.

So from what our accountant explained to us, the medical expense portion typically isn't taxed the same way as like, a regular settlement. The part that covers past medical bills and ongoing treatment generally gets different treatment than the part for lost wages or pain and suffering. But here's where it gets messy - it really depends on how the settlement is structured and worded. Our lawyer made sure to itemize everything really clearly in the agreement we got back in October so our tax person would know exactly what fell into each category.

I'm not gonna pretend I fully understand it because I don't, but what I do know is that you absolutely need someone who handles this stuff regularly. Our regular accountant literally said "you need to talk to someone who does settlements" so we ended up having to pay extra to bring in a specialist for that part. It sucked financially but it was worth not screwing it up. Like, I think we paid maybe a couple hundred dollars for that consultation and it saved us from making a huge mistake.

The biggest thing I wish I'd known earlier is that you want to nail down the language before the settlement is finalized, not after. So if your mom's case is moving toward that, make sure her legal team is being really specific about what money is for what.

You're doing so much right now. Seriously. Sitting in your car and crying is completely normal and honestly I do that in the Trader Joe's parking lot sometimes after I pick up her prescriptions. You're handling way more than one person should have to.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
Oh, the car crying thing... I know that spot so well. So many caregivers have described almost that exact same ritual and there's nothing wrong with it. It's actually a healthy release valve when everything else is maxed out.

On the tax question, this is something that comes up constantly in the groups I run. The general rule, and please run this by a CPA who specifically handles personal injury or wrongful death settlements because your regular accountant may not see these often enough, is that compensation tied to physical injury and illness is typically excluded from gross income under section 104 of the tax code. So money meant to cover your mom's medical costs, her physical pain and suffering, that portion generally isn't taxable. But punitive damages and anything tied to lost wages or emotional distress that isn't directly connected to physical harm, that can get taxed. It's genuinely more complicated than most people expect and the split between categories matters a lot.

One family I worked with at Banner MD Anderson here in Phoenix was really caught off guard when their accountant of 15 years said she'd never handled one of these before. They ended up finding a CPA through their attorney's referral network and it made a real difference.

The overwhelm you're feeling is real and makes complete sense. When it gets to be too much, I'd gently suggest talking to someone, even a few sessions with a counselor who works with caregivers, because what you're carrying is a lot for one person.
3 found this helpful
Medical ✓ Expert Response
What you're carrying right now is genuinely a lot, and sitting in your car and crying before you go home doesn't mean you're failing. It means you're human and you're exhausted.

On the tax question, here's what I've seen families go through in my 12 years working in oncology. Generally speaking, the portion of a settlement that's for physical injury and medical expenses tends to be excluded from federal income tax under IRC Section 104. So money specifically tied to your mom's illness and treatment costs is usually not taxable. But portions allocated for things like lost wages or punitive damages typically are. The tricky part is that how the settlement is structured and documented really matters, and that's where things get complicated fast.

When one family I worked with settled in 2019, their regular accountant was a good person but had genuinely never seen a mesothelioma case before. They ended up consulting a CPA who specifically handles personal injury settlements and it saved them from some real mistakes on how the allocations were reported. Not every accountant knows this area well and there's no shame in that, it's just specialized.

I'd also gently say that carrying the emotional weight of all of this alongside the financial logistics is a lot for one person. If the overwhelm starts feeling persistent, talking to a counselor who works with caregivers specifically can make a real difference. The Cancer Support Community has free services and their number is 1-888-793-9355.

You're asking the right questions. That matters.
2 found this helpful
Family
Honestly, I needed to hear that first part more than I needed the tax answer. Thank you for not making me feel like I'm being dramatic about the crying in my car thing because some days I feel like I should just be handling this better. The IRC Section 104 part actually makes sense too - so basically if it's explicitly for medical stuff and her actual injury, that chunk doesn't get taxed, but anything for like lost wages or pain and suffering might be different? I'm gonna write that down because my brain is already full today and I know I'll forget by the time I talk to our accountant.
Family
Oh man I'm so glad you asked this because I was in the exact same place like two months ago and just kept googling "mesothelioma settlement taxes" at 11pm which was not helping my anxiety lol. So here's what I learned from our situation.

The medical expense parts typically aren't taxed, which was huge for us. Like the portion that covers her actual treatment costs and ongoing care, that's usually protected. But the lost wages part and any general damages for pain and suffering, yeah that gets taxed as income. It's split up in the settlement agreement itself so your lawyers should be breaking down exactly what falls into each category before you even sign anything.

We ended up getting a CPA who specializes in this stuff because our regular accountant was kind of lost, honestly. I found someone through a recommendation from the lawyer's office and it cost like $400 to have them review everything and file it correctly, which felt worth it for the peace of mind. You don't have to do that but I'm glad we did because there are specific forms and ways to report it that are different from regular income.

And hey, you're not stupid for not knowing this. I have a master's degree and I felt stupid too. This is just not something normal people are supposed to know about and the fact that you're trying to figure it out while teaching and managing all her appointments shows you're actually doing an incredible job even though it probably doesn't feel like it. I sat in my car crying last week too so you're definitely not alone in that part.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
This is genuinely one of the more complicated tax situations people face, and the conflicting information you're getting is because the answer really does depend on how the settlement is structured.

The general rule under IRC Section 104 is that compensation for physical injury or illness is not taxable. So the portion tied to her pain and suffering, medical expenses, and physical harm from the asbestos exposure typically comes out tax-free. That's the bulk of most mesothelioma settlements, which is some good news.

Where it gets complicated is lost wages and punitive damages. Lost wages are usually taxable because they replace income that would have been taxed anyway. And punitive damages, if any are awarded, are taxable. Your regular accountant can handle this but I'd honestly make sure they have experience with personal injury settlements specifically, not just general tax prep. I've seen situations where a well-meaning accountant misclassified settlement proceeds and created a real headache.

One thing that matters a lot is how the settlement agreement is written. The language used to describe each portion of the payment can affect how the IRS treats it. A tax attorney who handles personal injury cases, or a CPA with that background, can sometimes work with the attorneys before the settlement is finalized to make sure the documentation reflects the medical nature of the damages accurately.

Please do talk to your mom's oncologist and her legal team about this together. And I'd say the same thing I tell patients' families in clinic, the fact that you're sitting in your car crying in a school parking lot before going home tells me you're carrying a lot right now. That's real, and it makes sense.
2 found this helpful
Family
Oh my god, thank you for actually breaking this down. So the pain and suffering part is what doesn't get taxed, that makes sense. Does that mean we should ask her settlement lawyer to specifically itemize it that way when they structure the deal, or is that something they already do automatically? I'm worried we'll mess something up if we don't ask the right questions.
Medical ✓ Expert Response
What you're carrying right now is genuinely a lot. Teaching, caregiving, crying in a parking lot before you drive home... that's not weakness, that's someone who has run out of hours in the day.

On the actual tax question, from what I've seen working with families going through settlements, the general rule under IRC Section 104 is that compensation for physical injury and medical expenses is typically not taxable. So the portion tied to her diagnosis, pain and suffering, and medical costs usually doesn't get touched. Where it gets complicated is things like punitive damages or interest, those portions often are taxable. And lost wages is a gray area that genuinely depends on how the settlement is structured in the paperwork.

Here's what I watched happen with a family I worked with back in 2019 at the cancer center, they brought their regular accountant in and he was honest that mesothelioma settlements have enough quirks that he referred them to a CPA who specifically handles personal injury settlements. That one referral saved them from a really painful surprise come April. Worth asking your accountant directly if they've handled asbestos settlements before.

The American Cancer Society has a financial navigation program that can sometimes connect families with pro bono tax guidance too, so that's worth a call.

And please, if the car crying becomes something you're doing every single day, I'd gently encourage talking to someone. What you're experiencing has a real name in the grief literature and you don't have to white-knuckle through it alone.
2 found this helpful

Share Your Experience

Sign in or create a free account to share your experience.

Sign In Create Account

Discussions in this community are for informational and emotional support purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice, medical advice, or an attorney-client relationship. Always consult a qualified professional for advice specific to your situation. Community Guidelines

Call Now: (800) 400-1805 Free Case Review • Available 24/7